You are just another MSM believer and China hater. Don't pretend you care about China or what you said make any sense.Absolute yes, the bubble has burst already. These stupid policies have been dragging down normal property transactions, thereby affecting the economy and people's livelihood. Just like zero-covid policies, the policies are outdated and are now hurting the people they wanted to help. All these stimulus are needless at this time, when the most effective remedy is to relax these useless restrictive policies.
Firstly, if you ended the restrictions now, then China could have another property super cycle just like 2016. That means the prices of housing would go to the roof. Been there and done that. China shouldn't make a mistake twice.
Secondly, over reliance on land sales has been a problem for China for so many years. This is an opportunity to end that reliance and get things back to normal. Housing is for living and not for investing or speculating.
Lastly, a few property developers need to file bankruptcy. These companies have been siphoning Chinese money out of China through abnormal high interest rate bond sales and dividends. They shouldn't be allowed to continue using easy money from banks and buyers for their own gains and jack up the home prices and get away with it.
In the end of the day, China should do enough to prevent a free fall of home prices and transactions. Many used home prices have dropped back to 2018 in many cities and some buyers have already gotten back in the market. Some new homes that priced 30% lower were bought in a few days. That means demands are there but people just wait for the right moment and opportunity to buy a home.
And I am absolutely against further allowing these property developers and speculators to again jack up home prices. Many of these speculators have a few, a few dozens, or even a few hundreds apartments that sitting empty and waiting for the price to go up. These speculators need to be dealt with and understood that the good old days of jacking up home prices have ended.