China Flanker Thread III (land based, exclude J-15)

Franklin

Captain
I think it was brought up in other thread, but the future of flankers with PLA is kind of interesting. How many more flankers do they need if J-20s are going gangbusters at 100 a year or even more than that.

Recently, we saw photo for 1105. In the past, most batches have been 24 aircraft (with a couple at 26 according to lyman). Since 2020, we are getting 2 batches every year (so 48). batch 11 is the first batch of this year and batch 12 will be the second. By the end of this year, we will probably be looking at 12 batches totally close to 300 J-16s. On top of that, it looks like we are getting 1 batch of J-16Ds a year. Not sure how many per batch. Maybe 10 to 12?

Depending on # of J-15s, it looks to me that producing 60 flankers a year is not a problem for them. Even 70 a year is quite doable.

Given that we still have brigades of JH-7A to replace, I wonder how many more J-16s we need. On the conservative end, 100 more is probably needed. On the high end, maybe 250 more will be built (so 50 a year for 5 more years). That doesn't include the need for maybe 100 J-16Ds and another 100 or more J-15s.

If we assume that they get to 300 J-16s by the end of this year, it's quite possible they get to 500 before J-35 production ramps up. At which point, it really doesn't make sense to produce any new J-16s.
In a few years the Flanker production will likely stop when the J-35 comes into production. In the meantime there are still a lot of J-7's, J-8's and JH-7's that need to be replaced. Even the J-11A's, J-10A's, SU27SK's and the SU-30MKK's need to be replaced. So they can keep producing J-16 and J-16D's in the coming years until J-35 production starts.
 

Jingle Bells

Junior Member
Registered Member
In a few years the Flanker production will likely stop when the J-35 comes into production. In the meantime there are still a lot of J-7's, J-8's and JH-7's that need to be replaced. Even the J-11A's, J-10A's, SU27SK's and the SU-30MKK's need to be replaced. So they can keep producing J-16 and J-16D's in the coming years until J-35 production starts.
I think it depends on how many J-16s the PLAAF really need, as well as whether J-35 will be deemed a suitable successor to heavy fighter/bombers like Su-30 and JH7A. In my opinion, J-35 will likely replace all J7 units, some J8 units and some J-11 units. J-16 will replace the Su-30s, JH7 units and the remainder of the J8 and J11 units.

I think the need for a non-stealthy heavy twin engine multirole fighter won't be gone for quite a long time.
 

tphuang

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
VIP Professional
Registered Member
In a few years the Flanker production will likely stop when the J-35 comes into production. In the meantime there are still a lot of J-7's, J-8's and JH-7's that need to be replaced. Even the J-11A's, J-10A's, SU27SK's and the SU-30MKK's need to be replaced. So they can keep producing J-16 and J-16D's in the coming years until J-35 production starts.
Have you looked at how many brigades of older planes there are? At the current pace of replacement, those aircraft will be gone in a couple of years.
 

Franklin

Captain
Have you looked at how many brigades of older planes there are? At the current pace of replacement, those aircraft will be gone in a couple of years.
These are the best numbers I can find. Most likely inaccurate if you have better numbers please share.

SU-30MKK (97)

J-10A (240)

J-11A (104)

SU-27SK (32)

JH-7 (270)

J-8 (122)

J-7 (340)

Total (1205)
 

tphuang

Lieutenant General
Staff member
Super Moderator
VIP Professional
Registered Member
These are the best numbers I can find. Most likely inaccurate if you have better numbers please share.

SU-30MKK (97)

J-10A (240)

J-11A (104)

SU-27SK (32)

JH-7 (270)

J-8 (122)

J-7 (340)

Total (1205)
scramble is what I use
Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

Looks like they have a couple of J-8FR brigades, but no real J-8 brigades anymore.

For J-7s, if we ignore the ones listed in there for flight academy and withdrawn from use or stated to be accepting new units, we are down to
44th, 88th, 97th, 63rd, 86th, 57th, 20th, 53rd, 52nd, 132nd, 71st, 21st -> 12 brigades
My guess is that the real number is less than this, since there are a couple of J-20/J-16/J-10C brigades which haven't been revealed yet. My guess is about 300 left.

JH-7s seem to be gone and we are left with 5 JH-7A brigades in PLAAF and 3 in PLAN, so about 240?

but my point is that they are adding 150 aircraft a year at least right now and that pace is probably going to go up over the course of this decade. They are going to be able to replace all the J-7 and su-27SK, + a good chunk of J-11A/su-30mkk/JH-7A in 5 years. At which point, you are probably ready to mass produce J-35. There aren't that many older aircraft to get rid of.
 

AndrewS

Brigadier
Registered Member
I think it was brought up in other thread, but the future of flankers with PLA is kind of interesting. How many more flankers do they need if J-20s are going gangbusters at 100 a year or even more than that.

Recently, we saw photo for 1105. In the past, most batches have been 24 aircraft (with a couple at 26 according to lyman). Since 2020, we are getting 2 batches every year (so 48). batch 11 is the first batch of this year and batch 12 will be the second. By the end of this year, we will probably be looking at 12 batches totally close to 300 J-16s. On top of that, it looks like we are getting 1 batch of J-16Ds a year. Not sure how many per batch. Maybe 10 to 12?

Depending on # of J-15s, it looks to me that producing 60 flankers a year is not a problem for them. Even 70 a year is quite doable.

Given that we still have brigades of JH-7A to replace, I wonder how many more J-16s we need. On the conservative end, 100 more is probably needed. On the high end, maybe 250 more will be built (so 50 a year for 5 more years). That doesn't include the need for maybe 100 J-16Ds and another 100 or more J-15s.

If we assume that they get to 300 J-16s by the end of this year, it's quite possible they get to 500 before J-35 production ramps up. At which point, it really doesn't make sense to produce any new J-16s.

I don't see it being worthwhile to ramp up Flanker airframe capacity from current levels.

If they're producing 50 per year, I reckon that would be sufficient to cover requirements for naval J-15s, SEAD J-16D and some J-16 additions every year.

And I don't see any rush to replace the JH-7A as these operate as bomb/missile trucks and the aircraft are all less than 20 years old
 

Franklin

Captain
I think once all the J-7's and the J-8's are all decommissioned the PLAAF should slowdown in its fighter procurement at least the Flankers. And focus more on stockpiling air to air missile's, PGM's and invest in more advanced jamming pods, targeting pods and HMS. Those things are just as important as the planes itself. That is the lesson from the war in Ukraine. And maybe more resources should go to the ground forces which in my view has been neglected in the modernization drive. Which mainly focusses on the air force and navy.
 
Top