Star Wars & Sc-Fi Talk

uguduwa

Junior Member
Registered Member
Anyone watching For All Mankknd? I just tried to watch it a few times but just can‘t get past the bullshit melodrama. I find the concept amazing but they butchered it. A better way would have been to tell the story in the perspective of an employee in NASA going from intern to director while telling all the events in between.
 

SCE2Aux

New Member
Registered Member
Watched through, and despite some interesting elements, I wasn't really impressed overall. The melodrama was truly excessive, at time it felt like I was watching daytime soap operas... The other thing that's increasingly mystifying is insufficient focus on Chinese spaceflight efforts. They really have a blindspot on that side of things.
 

CasualObserver

Senior Member
Registered Member
They know that people watch it for the far-fetched what-if, not the “but oh, I can’t come out as gay as the first female president!” propaganda/melodrama… Guess what they keep going for?

I also have lots of nitpicks and thematic criticisms; nevertheless, that’s another matter since I want to keep this short.

If you’re interested, divert your attention elsewhere and don’t make the same mistake I did.
 

uguduwa

Junior Member
Registered Member
It‘s not even the wokeness that bugs me. , kt‘s stuff like some astronaut‘s wife banging some dead astronaut‘s son. Of all things they can show, all themes they can explore, they do this. I would have watched a series that‘s completely about Margo‘s rise. She was the most interesting character in that show exactly because she‘s workaholic.
 

Racek49

Junior Member
Registered Member
Watched through, and despite some interesting elements, I wasn't really impressed overall. The melodrama was truly excessive, at time it felt like I was watching daytime soap operas... The other thing that's increasingly mystifying is insufficient focus on Chinese spaceflight efforts. They really have a blindspot on that side of things.
Well, I consider it one of the best and quite realistic series, the romance there is quite bearable - don't be offended, but in almost every historical series from China there is much more of it - I otherwise like historical series and many Chinese ones are very good and I consider this melodrama as a local specialty and I don't mind it at all...
Well, the first two parts. When they go to Mars, it gets a bit boring but still good.
At that time, in the sixties and seventies, I was a big fan of astronautics and I experienced reality. That's probably why I appreciate that line so much -- what if everything had been different and the Russians had been the first on the moon, it was quite realistic, if not for the two-year interrupted development of the N1 rocket and Glushko's reluctance to supply suitable engines because he hated Korolev, but you probably already know that --
I just finished watching the Chinese series about Admiral Zheng He from 2009, it was finally with subtitles... beautiful, although sometimes the tricks are worse than today, but you know that... and melodrama to the max. But I really enjoyed it and was excited ... of course, sometimes the villain may not have been such a villain and vice versa... but that's everywhere, isn't it?
The advantage of China is that the screenwriters don't even have to invent much. China's history is really too rich. Okay, I'm just starting Three Kingdoms from 2010, unfortunately with Iranian subtitles and the translation is not very good. Well, you can get used to it.
 

vincent

Grumpy Old Man
Staff member
Moderator - World Affairs
Well, I consider it one of the best and quite realistic series, the romance there is quite bearable - don't be offended, but in almost every historical series from China there is much more of it - I otherwise like historical series and many Chinese ones are very good and I consider this melodrama as a local specialty and I don't mind it at all...
Well, the first two parts. When they go to Mars, it gets a bit boring but still good.
At that time, in the sixties and seventies, I was a big fan of astronautics and I experienced reality. That's probably why I appreciate that line so much -- what if everything had been different and the Russians had been the first on the moon, it was quite realistic, if not for the two-year interrupted development of the N1 rocket and Glushko's reluctance to supply suitable engines because he hated Korolev, but you probably already know that --
I just finished watching the Chinese series about Admiral Zheng He from 2009, it was finally with subtitles... beautiful, although sometimes the tricks are worse than today, but you know that... and melodrama to the max. But I really enjoyed it and was excited ... of course, sometimes the villain may not have been such a villain and vice versa... but that's everywhere, isn't it?
The advantage of China is that the screenwriters don't even have to invent much. China's history is really too rich. Okay, I'm just starting Three Kingdoms from 2010, unfortunately with Iranian subtitles and the translation is not very good. Well, you can get used to it.
Try this series, A biopic Qin Shihuang, the most important man in Chinese history.

Playlist:
Code:
Please, Log in or Register to view codes content!
 
Top