My Review and Build of Dragon Model's 1/350 scale Kit #1028,
The USS Preble, DDG-88, Arleigh Burke Flight IIA AEGIS Destroyer
Introduction and What's in the Box - March 22, 2012
Overview - Some differences between Dragon Models and Trumpeter:
Dragon Models is one of the pre-iminent manufacturers of 1/350 scale model warships, particularly from my perspective, modern warships. They are in a stiff competition with Trumpter Models. This kit, Dragon Model's Kit number 1028, is of the USS Preble, a Flight IIA Arleigh Burke class AEGIS destroyer. I built the , also a Arleigh Burke IIA AEGIS destroyer, and I am adding them both to my US Navy Carrier Strike Group centered on the , specifically for the purpose of comparing the two.
Generally, Trumpeter models are more expensive (averaging $20 or more for the suggested retail price for the same model), than Dragon. This is because generally Trumpeter models have many more parts and a lot more individual detail, while Dragon molds a lot of good detail into the ships themselves, rather than producing individual parts. In addition, usually some major detail options such as a waterline option, or open and detailed internal hangar bays are options you get with a Trumpeter model and not with a Dragon Model. That is the case (in both instances) with this model by Dragon, the USS Preble, when compared to the USS Lassen by Trumpeter. I will point out more on the specific differences as I go along with the build.
Introduction - Arleigh Burke Destroyers:
The Flight IIA Arleigh Burke class AEGIS destoryers have developed into the main stay of the United States Navy surface combatant fleet. The Burke destroyers have been built thus far in three batches. The initial batch starting with DDG-51, the USS Arleigh Burke commissioned in 1991, through DDG-71, the USS Ross, commissioned in 1997, which had 90 VLS cells and no helicopter hangar. The Flight II batch started with DDG-72, the USS Mahan commissioned in 1998, through DDG-78, the USS Porter commissioned in 1999 which had slight improivements and modifications over the initial batch, but were essentially the same in overall function. Then the Flight IIA batch, of which the USS Preble is a part, starting with DDG-79, the USS Oscar Austin, commissioned in 2000, and proceeding through DDG-112, the USS Michael Murphy commissioned in 2012, which were major changes, adding a full two helicopter hangar, increasing the number of available VLS cells, and removing some of the other weapons systems (like the eight deck mounted cannister launched Harpoon missiles). Four or five more Flight IIA vessels will be built over ther next 3-4 years.
To date, 62 Arleigh Burke AEGIS destroyers have been built, 33 of them Flight IIA vessels. Ultimately Flight IIA will end with a total of 37 or 38 vessels. Originally the Michale Murphey, DDG-112 was planned to be the last Arleigh Burke destroyer and she was commissioned into service in October of 2012. But with the new <A href="http://www.jeffhead.com/usn21/ddg1000.htm">DDG-1000 Zumwalt class destroyers</a> now being limited to a total build of three vessels, and with the cancellation of the CGX program that was to replace the Ticonderoga Class AEGIS crusiers, the US Navy is now planning a Flight III batch of Arleigh Burke class destroyers (an example of what that DDG may look like can be seen <a href="http://www.jeffhead.com/aegisvesselsoftheworld/burke3.htm">HERE</a>) that will fill the gap between current technology (including some of the new technology included on the Zumwalts) and a future CG or DDG combatant to be designed in the mid to late 2020s. Right now, construction on Flight III ships is meant to start in 2016 and will produce anywhere from 12 to 30 vessels. To get the US Navy to the Flight III build, the 4 or 5 more Flight IIA vessels are being built.
The Arleigh Burke class destroyers carry the much vaunted and respected AEGIS intergrated combat systemn which can control all weapons on the destroyer, and is Cooperative Engagement (CE) capable and able to control the combat systems of other ships and aircraft, which would be slaved into the AEGIS system of the controlling ship for those platforms that have the CE capabbility.
The vessels use powerful Phased Array Radars (PARs) to find and indetify targets, vertical launch cells (90 on the Flight I and II ships and 96 on the Flight IIA ships), to fire anti-air, anti-submarine, and-ballistic missile, anti-surface, and anti-shipping guided missiles against those targets. They also carry a 5" (127mm) main gun, two 2omm Phalanx CIWS, two Mk-38 25mm cannons, two three torpedo tube luanchers, two SH-60 helicopters, and a large variety of strong electronic counter measure capabilities and chaff and decoy launchgers. The Arleigh Burke Flight IIA guided missile destroyers are recognized as the most powerful large group of mulit-mission destroyers on earth and are a vital part of the US NAvy's overall mission to ensure the safety of, and the freedom of sea transit throughout the world.
Introduction - The USS Preble, DDG-88:
The Preble itself was laid down on June 22, 2000, launched on June 1, 2001, and commissioned into the US Navy on November 9, 2002. She is a part of the US Navy's 3rd Fleet (the Pacific Fleet), and is based in San Diego. She has served in both Iraqi Freedom and Enduring Freedom, the war in Afganistan, serving as aan escort for US aircraft Carriers Strike Groups (CSG) and Amphibuious Ready Groups (ARG) participating in those combat situations. She has also served in numerous operations and training exercises each year, and on individual missions and exercises.
The Preble is powered by four General Electric Gas Turbine Engines which provide a combined 100,000 horsepower (75 MW) and power the ship through the water at over 30 knots. She is over 500 feet long, 66 feet wide and displaces well over 9,000 tons. She has a crew of 33 Officers, 38 Chief Petty officers, and 210 enlisted sailors.
Her armament consists of a 32 cell MK-41 VLS System forward and a 64 cell Mk-41 VLS system aft. As stated, these 96 vertical launch cells can launch standard anti-air missiles, standard anti-balistic missile missiles, Tomahawk land attack missiles, Tomahaw anti-shipping missiles, and ASROC anti-submarine rocket launched torpedoes. They can also fire Evolved Sea Sparrow anti-air missiles which can be quad packed in individual cells. The vessle is also armed with a 5" (127mm) 64 caliber main, dual-purpose (DP) gun, two 20mm Phalanx Close in Weapon Systems (CIWS), two Mk-38 25mm cannons, and two, three tube torpedo launchers for Mk-54 anti-submarine torpedoes. She also has a full hangar and large helo pad aft for two SH-60 heclipoters which can conduct a variety of missions from anti-submarine warfare, to anti-surface warfare, to Search and Rescue (SAR), to recon and replenshiment.
What's in the Box:
This Dragon Model's kit comes in a beautifully illustrated box, that is well built and very protective. It also has numerous pictures around the box that depict the various features of the model, including the fact that the model comes with two Photo Etch sheets and a very complete set of decals. Inside, the hull comes in a single piece. It is a very well molded and detailed pieces with a few exceptions.
- 1st, there is a slight seam line down the middle of the hull on the bottom. It can be sanded or filed away (and on the sonar dome at the forward part of the vessel you will want to do this). The rest is in a place where you may rarely notice it, but it is there.
- 2nd, the landing deck is somewhat too long. The hangar should actually be longer and the landing deck a little shorter. Since there is not a provision for an internal hangar this is not too terrible of an issue, but in order to fix the model dimensionally, the portion of the hull where it drops off from the main deck to the aft landing deck would have to be moved back slightly and that is a fairly major undertaking with a number of ripple effects to other pieces and assemblies on the model. Since there is no internal hangar in any case, I intend to let it ride because unless you are aware of it, it will not be noticable.
- 3rd is that in the model of the main hull, amidships, the hull itself is not stiff enough to avoid the upper portions of the hull wanting to warp inward and make the fit of the mid-ships main deck difficult. I address this in the build-up by adding my own "struts" to maintain the proper distance. It could also be addressed by having an extremly good clamping or mating system to hold the deck down into this section, forcing it apart to the right distance while it dries...but it is also something to be aware of. In addition, the mid-ships main deck assembly is slightly too long when the forward main deck, and the aft hangar is properly placed on the model. More on this in the build-up.
Anyhow, outside of that, as I say, the hull does have some really nice surface detail along both sides, including the bilge keels. There is no option for a waterline model here unless you painstakingly cut the bottom off the vessel and sratch build a base plate to fit to it.
There are five plastic sprues that come with this model, and two Photo Etch sheets. The various sprues contain all the parts you will need for the model, but they also contain a number of parts you will not use which Dragon (and other model makers including Trupmeter) place in the model as a cost savings measure so they do not have to package different versions of the model (Flight I and II vessels versus the Flight IIA version) with completely different bills of materials and molds. They just make a single mold to cover both and pump them out and include them in all models.
In this case, one of the problems is that the main mast does not include some of the minor differences that are present on the Flight IIA version of the model. These are relatively minor and can be fixed by removing what is necessary and adding the details, but it is something to be aware of. Also, the kit does not include the 25mm Mk-38 guns that have been added to all Arleigh Burke Flight IIA vessels after the USS Cole attack in Yemen. I purchased 25mm Mk-38 guns in 1/350 scale from White Ensign Models, and if you want to have them on the vessel, you will have to do something similar. More on this issue in the build. Finally, there are a couple of areas where the instructions do not call out the location of some of the parts at all, for example with the torpedo tubes, which it shows being assembled in a sub-assembly bullet, but then does not show where they should be placed. Or in the case on the top part of the hangar, towards the aft end of the hangar, there are several pieces that make up equipment that goes there (a shield, a small deck house, and aexhaust funnle, that are included with the boat, but never shown where they should go. In the absence of any knwledge of the vessels, my guess is that most model makers hust leave these out entirely. These parts are correctly called out, and have more details with the included replenishment parts, on the Trumpeter Flight IIA Models.
The plastic parts are well detailed and well molded. No noticable flash present. There are not the numbers or the intracies provided by the Trumpeter kit, and therefore less pieces, but the detail on the panels for the deck houses help make up for this, particularly if you have a steady hand for painting things like the small 1/350 scale life buoys and fire hoses which come as seperate parts in the Trumpeter model. The parts are molded in light gray and gold for the brass photo etched parts. I intend to use my standard US Navy paint scheme of Neutral Gray for all major vertical surfaces of the ship, a mix of 2 parts red and one part brown of Model Masters paints for the below water line hull, Flat Black for the waterline stripe and other flat black areas, Weathered Black for the funnels and the windows, Flight Deck Stain for the horizontal surfaces and Flat White for the radomes and life rafts. Other colors (such as Ensignia Orange for the life buoys), as required.
Now, having said all of that, finally, here are the initial parts out of the box.
The decals include names for ten different Flight IIA vessels. I intend to go ahead an build the Preble, DDG-88. They are also fairly complete with various markings for various awards for the vessel, and all of the warning markings and the forward replensihment spot...but sadly, there are no major makings (ouside of the hash markinhgs) for the helo landing deck. I expect Dragon intends you to pain those markings on in Flat White, and there are raised edges/lines for this. I intend to utilize after-market decals to do so, and decal set to ensure that they fold down around the raised surfaces properly. The decals that are there (and there are quite a few of them) are rather tightly packed on the sheet so you will have to be carful cutting them out when that time comes.
In addition, the instructions are fairly intuitive...and in a couple of cases they have to be because, a sstated, they leave out a couple of parts that are included and shown in some pictures, but never shown how they are to be put on. The paint scheme is not the glossy, color print you have come to expect from Trumpeter or Bronco or Gallery, but it is a decent paint scheme and gets the job done very adequately.