Pakistan Mosque Standoff

crazyinsane105

Junior Member
VIP Professional
Pakistani militants snub surrender call

By DENIS D. GRAY, Associated Press Writer 52 minutes ago

ISLAMABAD, Pakistan - Gunfire and explosions rocked a besieged radical mosque in Pakistan's capital Thursday as Islamic militants holed up in the complex snubbed a plea from their captured leader to surrender.
ADVERTISEMENT

The leader of the holdouts said they would consider leaving but only if authorities promised not to arrest anyone and met other demands. The government answered that the militants must surrender without conditions, and outbursts of gunfire erupted periodically during the night.

The army seemed to be holding back from a large-scale assault. The government was keen to avoid a bloodbath that would further damage President Gen. Pervez Musharraf's embattled administration and said troops would not storm the mosque while women and children were inside.

Interior Minister Aftab Khan Sherpao said soldiers were trying to blast holes in the walls of the fortress-like compound of the mosque and an adjoining seminary for girls, seeking to wear down the defenders' resolve and force a surrender without a bloody battle.

It wasn't clear how many people were holed up in the compound. The Interior Ministry said about 30 die-hard extremists were inside, while intelligence officials said there could be as many as 100. The military said several hundred students also might be in the compound.

Soldiers backed by armored vehicles and helicopters surrounded the Lal Masjid, or Red Mosque, before dawn Wednesday, a day after the start of clashes between security forces and radical followers of the mosque that have killed at least 19 people.

The violence brought to a head a six-month standoff between Pakistan's U.S.-backed government and its top cleric, Maulana Abdul Aziz, who challenged Musharraf with a drive to impose Taliban-style Islamic law in Islamabad.

Journalists were barred from the area around the mosque, but several explosions were heard during a period of intense gunfire before dusk Thursday, sending a plume of black smoke into the sky.

A leader inside the mosque accused troops of firing several mortar rounds that killed 27 female students.

"A large section of the mosque is damaged and fires have broken out in the Jamia Hafsa (seminary)," Abdul Qayyum told The Associated Press by telephone, coughing repeatedly. "It's total chaos here. There is smoke everywhere and a fire in the room where we were keeping dead bodies" from earlier skirmishes.

Sherpao insisted no mortars were fired and said the alleged casualties were "just their claims."

The shooting later eased and the smoke cleared.

Officials said they were using helicopters and explosions in hopes of breaking the nerve of the mosque defenders and inducing a surrender. "We are using restraint on instructions from the president so that people surrender voluntarily," Sherpao said.

Aziz, who was captured Wednesday evening as he tried to slip through the army cordon disguised in a woman's burqa and high heels, said on state television that as many as 700 women and about 250 men remained inside the complex, armed with more than a dozen AK-47 assault rifles.

"If they can get out quietly they should go, or they can surrender if they want to," Aziz said. "I saw after coming out that the siege is very intense. ... Our companions will not be able to stay for long."

His comments raised the prospect of a swift resolution and a victory for Musharraf, who is under growing pressure at home and abroad over spreading religious extremism and his botched attempt to fire Pakistan's chief justice.

But the cleric's brother, Abdul Rashid Ghazi, remained inside the mosque with their die-hard followers and rejected the government's call for an unconditional surrender.

Speaking by phone to Pakistan's Geo news channel, Ghazi demanded a guarantee they would not be arrested and said authorities must let him move his mother and sister-in-law out of the complex to safety.

He denied claims by officials that he was using young students as human shields. "The charges against me are forged and fabricated," he said. "The government has been reduced to callousness."

Qayyum, Ghazi's aide, declined to comment on the statement from Aziz or to describe living conditions in the compound, where power and water had been cut off for days.

Deputy Information Minister Tariq Azim said earlier that some of the 1,100 supporters who had fled the mosque and seminary told officials that Ghazi retreated to a cellar along with 20 female "hostages" and that the holdouts had "large quantities of automatic weapons." Officials said the militants also had hand grenades, explosives and homemade gasoline bombs.

Azim said there would be no more negotiations.

"Enough time has already been wasted. It has to be total, unconditional surrender," he said, but added: "As long as there are women and children inside, I don't think that we will go in."

On Thursday, seven men jumped over the mosque wall and tried to escape through a storm drain, but were caught by troops, said Col. Mohammed Ali, a military spokesman. He said the seven were "part of the hard core," but provided no other details.

Since January, the clerics have defied the government by sending students to occupy a library, intimidate shopkeepers selling Western music and films and kidnap alleged prostitutes and police officers as part of a Taliban-style anti-vice campaign.

In his TV interview, the gray-bearded Aziz, still dressed in a burqa, said that his mosque has "a relationship of love and affection with all jihadist organizations" but that it maintains no actual links with such groups.

"We have no militants; we only had students. If somebody came from outside, I have no information on that," he said. He denied responsibility for calls Tuesday from the mosque's loudspeakers for suicide attacks.

Officials said Aziz and Ghazi would be put on trial on more than 25 charges including kidnapping, incitement to murder and arms offenses, while women, children and males not involved in crimes were being granted amnesty.

Students emerging from the mosque Thursday said the morale of those who remained was good, and many stressed that they left only at the insistence of worried parents.

"They are in high spirits," Mehboob Waly said after exiting to meet his waiting father.

Mohammed Naveed, a teenager who responded to his mother's pleas for him to leave, said: "I came out with a heavy heart. I was scared to be inside, but I was also scared to come out."

Like many of the mosque's students, both are from northwestern Pakistan, an impoverished region where radical Islam is strong.



It seems inevitable that a military operation will take place. And unfortunately large scale assaults like these have never ended greatly (Beslan, Waco, the Kaaba incident in 1979, etc.) Any ideas as to what may or may not happen?
 

Finn McCool

Captain
Registered Member
A different story:

Please, Log in or Register to view URLs content!

It seems to me that these "militants" offered reasonable surrender terms and the government rejected them. I think Musharraf is trying to portray himself as the only thing saving Pakistan from Taliban style rule. It seems to me that the rejection of this offer was intended to prolong the crisis so that Musharraf can enhance his own "tough on fundamentalism" credentials and at the same time draw public attention to bearded radicals with guns. It makes him look good in comparison. What grinds my gears is that the headline on the story is "Militants snub surrender call" when really it was the other way around.
 

crazyinsane105

Junior Member
VIP Professional
It seems to me that these "militants" offered reasonable surrender terms and the government rejected them. I think Musharraf is trying to portray himself as the only thing saving Pakistan from Taliban style rule. It seems to me that the rejection of this offer was intended to prolong the crisis so that Musharraf can enhance his own "tough on fundamentalism" credentials and at the same time draw public attention to bearded radicals with guns. It makes him look good in comparison. What grinds my gears is that the headline on the story is "Militants snub surrender call" when really it was the other way around.

Problem is that they were offered a way out even before the shooting began. The Pakistani goverment actually spent six months trying to negotiate with these guys. The negotitations were very very long and well documented, but the clerics and their die hard supporters wanted nothing less than a full Taliban style state in Pakistan. The militants were the ones that opened fire on the military, thus effectively declaring hostilities. These guys were given six months to make up their mind, but now once the rope is being tightened around their necks are they are wanting to surrender. They don't want to be arrested or face any type of prosecution for their actions. Following their demands will only embolden other cults as the punishment is not severe at all. A lesson needs to be made out of these folks so other groups will think a hundred times before trying to pull this stupid stunt.
 
D

Deleted member 675

Guest
What grinds my gears is that the headline on the story is "Militants snub surrender call" when really it was the other way around.

But they're the criminals - why do they get to put conditions down on their surrender? They should give themselves up like anyone else.
 

bd popeye

The Last Jedi
VIP Professional
Unfortunatley the whole incident may end in a bloddy battle with innocents killed along with the guilty..

Pakistani Ranger reads a newspaper during a calm moment in the battle between Taliban-style militants and Pakistan army rangers in Islamabad, Pakistan, on 06 July 2007. Lal Masjid clerics took thousands of students hostage and wanted to impose strict Islamic sharia law all over the country. Earlier they burned DVD's, kidnapped policemen and Chinese massage parlour workers in the capital. EPA/OLIVIER MATTHYS

2nd pic...Pakistani paramilitary soldiers escort religious students of besieged Red Mosque who surrendered to authorities in Islamabad Pakistan 06 July 2007. Hardcore militants in Islamabad Friday prepared their wills as security forces tightened the stranglehold on a besieged mosque where they have been holed up for the last four days. Authorities were confirming 19 casualties, including two soldiers and one journalist, in the four-day standoff. The extremist administration of the mosque has been in a standoff with the authorities for the past five months over its attempts to impose a strict, Taliban-style way of life on the citizens of the Pakistani capital based on Islamic sharia law. EPA/T. MUGHAL
 

Attachments

  • 0ff7e4a5.jpg
    0ff7e4a5.jpg
    34.9 KB · Views: 7
  • 6abbbafd.jpg
    6abbbafd.jpg
    86.4 KB · Views: 8
  • 97e289e4.jpg
    97e289e4.jpg
    80.8 KB · Views: 8
Last edited:

bd popeye

The Last Jedi
VIP Professional
More pictures of Pakistani forces during the siege...

Pakistan rangers in armed personnel carriers (APC) close in on the Red Mosque in Islamabad, Pakistan, on 05 July 2007. Over 600 Pakistani Taliban supporting female and male students have so far surrendered to the rangers Two days and nights long shootout left at least 14 dead and over 100 injured. The Lal Masjid is completely surrounded and a curfew is imposed around its neighborhood. Hardliners are still resisting and return fire. EPA/OLIVIER MATTHYS

4th picture,... Pakistani paramilitary soldiers arrest religious students who were trying to escape the beseiged Red Mosque in Islamabad, Pakistan, 05 July 2007. Pakistani security forces launched successive warning assaults on a besieged mosque in the centre of Islamabad after hardcore militant students ignored government calls for unconditional surrender.
 

Attachments

  • 121c9984.jpg
    121c9984.jpg
    67.7 KB · Views: 8
  • 36211f16.jpg
    36211f16.jpg
    60.2 KB · Views: 7
  • c3ecd1c6.jpg
    c3ecd1c6.jpg
    75.8 KB · Views: 7
  • 483fe7a5.jpg
    483fe7a5.jpg
    89.2 KB · Views: 10
Last edited:

Finn McCool

Captain
Registered Member
I can't see this situation ending well, either for the those inside the mosque or Pakistan at large. It seems likely that this will end in a battle. Similarly, it seems that Pakistan's problems with radical Islam and civil unrest there will only increase as the Musharraf government continues to weaken. Given the examples on display throughout the Middle East, it seems unlikely that Pakistani civil society and moderates, so long beaten down by the military government, will be able to stand up to the Islamists. Which is why it seems that the Army will continue to keep control and play the moderates/political parties off against the Islamists. However the Islamists in Pakistan are no longer simply a tool of the Army and the ISI as this present situation shows.
 

maglomanic

Junior Member
It seems the situation has turned into a hostage drama. It is being said that there are afghans and uzbuks among the die hard fighters inside the mosque who are stopping the students from leaving and might even have forced the alleged mosque leader into toeing their line. His brother the actual head of the mosque was arrested trying to run away wearing ladies' burka. Both the brothers have been lying and showing stubborness for past six months.

The govt has moved in very intelligently. Over 1100 students have come out. there are still few hundred inside and their parents have tried to bring them but they were pushed back by the militants, which is why it is being said that this has turned into a hostage situation. Then the ones who have come out told about forced incarceration.

The strategy seems to be that the militants are being provked into using up all their supplies and constant pressure without really pushing them to wall. the deadlines have been increased time and againand all that has resulted in mass evacuations of students.

regarding the Pakistanis reaction to al this drama? Well overwhleming majority has turned against these mullahs and their madaresah system. If you could watch what is being shown in Pakistani media (which is not toeing govt's position at all), most people are showing great anger against these militants and supporting govt on this.
 
Last edited:

flyzies

Junior Member
Problem is that they were offered a way out even before the shooting began. The Pakistani goverment actually spent six months trying to negotiate with these guys. The negotitations were very very long and well documented, but the clerics and their die hard supporters wanted nothing less than a full Taliban style state in Pakistan. The militants were the ones that opened fire on the military, thus effectively declaring hostilities. These guys were given six months to make up their mind, but now once the rope is being tightened around their necks are they are wanting to surrender. They don't want to be arrested or face any type of prosecution for their actions. Following their demands will only embolden other cults as the punishment is not severe at all. A lesson needs to be made out of these folks so other groups will think a hundred times before trying to pull this stupid stunt.

Very well said...
A country's leadership should never give in to the demands of terrorists...domestic or foreign. Period.
Giving the terrorists what they want will only cause them to do the same thing again next time they're after something...
 
Top