Agree. Soft power and some random country and it people view/ opinions is pretty much irrelevant. Besides no matter how much soft power China have can't changes the mind of China haters. Talk about borders between Russia and China make me want to tell story of China hater visit some Russia town/city in border with China. He wants to depict those town as some lovely places but in reality because it geographic it just some dark, boring, lack of spirit/ vitality place. And he also remark: people here(Russian) use to be honest and sincere or almost naive etc. But after few decades of trading and communicate with Chinese they learn some trick and become less honest and more evil. Implied that Russian is good boys got seductive by evil Chinese. Lol just convenient forgot to mention how those good boys can grab the land and live in the land of evils Chinese in first place.Reputation huh? Now we are going back to the soft power vs hard power thing again.
You know with all that has happened in just the last few years, I am more convinced that soft power is overrated as hell and really is a second thought to hard power.
I remember people whining about how China has crap soft power and reputation and how they are jealous of places like Japan or South Korea who have it. Well now both are seen as old aging has-been vassal states with low birth rates who now need to consider asking immigrants to come to their countries to save them. South Korea has went up and fallen down in such a short time its amazing. Like they have a president who thought it was a good idea to declare martial law without a plan, Samsung and others are losing out, their sporting performance is going down hill, Kpop is no longer as cool etc.
Meanwhile China who has been slandered for years and years is suddenly "cool". Get real. The reason China is "cool" is the cumulation of decades of hard work to get its technology, living standards, infrastructure etc to world class while everyone else was mocking it. It didn't need to do a huge advertisement show of its weapons. The recent fight between India and Pakistan let China's prowess prove itself on the battlefield rather than arguing on the internet about how good it was on paper. Basically China's prowess can simply no longer be denied and now people are forced to accept it.
Anyway where I am going with this is if China was to do something, its less to do with reputation and more to do with being practical. It is not practical to start landgrabbing Russia when it has its hands full already with US, Taiwan, Philippines, Japan and even India. China already has enough guys to deal with, it doesn't need to make another one. Not having to worry about the north or west parts of China is something it has almost never seen before.
Its just frustrating to watch Russia at the moment given how good it was on paper. Russia is strong enough so it doesn't need China's help etc. Thats fine but please actually live up to it. Otherwise its like a teammate who says he can handle it and it turns out he can't so now the team is fucked.
People in the west know all the stories about how Russia stomped the swedes, french, germans, poles etc in Europe. What about the east? They simply moved east now equipped with guns thanks to advancement in technology and took over the nomadic guys who weren't strong like the mongols. The only reason they didn't get more is because Qing back when it was strong stopped them going any further. Thats really it. There's no major story or history there.Agree. Soft power and some random country and it people view/ opinions is pretty much irrelevant. Besides no matter how much soft power China have can't changes the mind of China haters. Talk about borders between Russia and China make me want to tell story of China hater visit some Russia town/city in border with China. He wants to depict those town as some lovely places but in reality because it geographic it just some dark, boring, lack of spirit/ vitality place. And he also remark: people here(Russian) use to be honest and sincere or almost naive etc. But after few decades of trading and communicate with Chinese they learn some trick and become less honest and more evil. Implied that Russian is good boys got seductive by evil Chinese. Lol just convenient forgot to mention how those good boys can grab the land and live in the land of evils Chinese in first place.
Soft power and reputation are extremely important for China because it gives them huge advantages in Asean, the Middle East, South America, Africa, and South Asia. Even if it did nothing for the China-haters (which isn't actually), China sticking to its principles still holds a lot of value.Agree. Soft power and some random country and it people view/ opinions is pretty much irrelevant. Besides no matter how much soft power China have can't changes the mind of China haters. Talk about borders between Russia and China make me want to tell story of China hater visit some Russia town/city in border with China. He wants to depict those town as some lovely places but in reality because it geographic it just some dark, boring, lack of spirit/ vitality place. And he also remark: people here(Russian) use to be honest and sincere or almost naive etc. But after few decades of trading and communicate with Chinese they learn some trick and become less honest and more evil. Implied that Russian is good boys got seductive by evil Chinese. Lol just convenient forgot to mention how those good boys can grab the land and live in the land of evils Chinese in first place.
noThis real? Niger requiring all CN personnels on Oil facilities there to leave by May31, (maybe some technicians will stay?) or else they will do "enforcement"? Why r they targeting CN investment there? Curious did Niger do similar to other investments there?
That is a historical absolute truth though. Every territorial claim is tied to how much power you have. Starship Troopers was right: the ultimate arbiter of truth is force.Lets be honest though, the only reason China allows Russia to have stuff that was previously Chinese lands is because of Russian military power. Russia's legitimacy is pretty much tied to how strong it is. If it doesn't have the strength, it has no justification for a lot of its land.
Obviously its way better for Russia to win this war with Ukraine. But Russia is only as good as it backs up with its fist.
While I think your points make sense, I don't you should use a satirical film as a source for your information.That is a historical absolute truth though. Every territorial claim is tied to how much power you have. Starship Troopers was right: the ultimate arbiter of truth is force.
What is the legitimate territory of the US, without force? Jamestown, Virginia and Plymouth Rock, Massachusetts. Every meter beyond that was taken with brute force or trickery backed by force.
Starship troopers is based on a novel by Robert Heinlein who is considered one of the pioneers of science fiction. The novel is also considered a staple of scifi. Heinlein being ex military will obviously have bias but at least can explain where he comes from.While I think your points make sense, I don't you should use a satirical film as a source for your information.
Who knows, some haters might cherry-pick it and show to others as proof of how we're stupid or something lol.